Consistent Theories in Inconsistent Logics
نویسندگان
چکیده
Abstract The relationship between logics with sets of theorems including contradictions (“inconsistent logics”) and theories closed under such is investigated. It noted that if we take “theories” to be defined in terms deductive closure understood a way somewhat different from the standard, Tarskian, one, inconsistent can have consistent theories. That is, find some formulas which logic need not contain any contradictions. We prove this general setting for family relevant connexive logics, extract essential features proof order obtain sufficient condition consistency theory arbitrary finally consider concrete examples mathematical Abelian logic. upshot on understanding closure, common there rich interesting kind interaction their argue suggests an important avenue investigation both technical philosophical perspective.
منابع مشابه
Consistent Subsets of Inconsistent Systems
A large knowledge system operating for a long time almost inevitably becomes \polluted" by wrong data that makes the system inconsistent. Despite this fact, a sizeable part of the system remains unpolluted, and retains useful information. It is widely adopted that a maximally consistent subset of a system (mc-subset) contains a sig-niicant portion of unpolluted data. So, determining mc-subsets ...
متن کاملArgumentative Logics: Reasoning with Classically Inconsistent Information
Classical logic has many appealing features for knowledge representation and reasoning. But unfortunately it is awed when reasoning about inconsistent information, since anything follows from a classical inconsistency. This problem is addressed by introducing the notions of \argument" and of \acceptability" of an argument. These notions are used to introduce the concept of \argumentative struct...
متن کاملFibring (Para)consistent Logics∗
The problem of fibring paraconsistent logics is addressed. Such logics raise new problems in the semantics of fibring since previous work assumed verum-functional models. The solution is found in a general notion of interpretation system presentation that “specifies” the intended valuations in some appropriate meta language. Fibring appears as a universal construction in the category of interpr...
متن کاملConsistent Good News and Inconsistent Bad News
Good news is more persuasive when it is more consistent, and bad news is less damaging when it is less consistent. We show when Bayesian updating supports this intuition so that a biased sender prefers more or less variance in the news depending on whether the mean of the news exceeds expectations, and we apply the result to selective news distortion by a manager of multiple projects. If news f...
متن کاملTime-consistent Individuals, Time-inconsistent Households
I present a model of consumption and savings for multi-person households in which members are imperfectly altruistic and share wealth. I show that, despite having standard exponential time preferences, the household is time-inconsistent: members save too little and overspend on private consumption goods. Access to private illiquid durable goods can exacerbate overconsumption by providing a way ...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Journal of Philosophical Logic
سال: 2023
ISSN: ['1573-0433', '0022-3611']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10992-023-09700-z